Monitoring at a London Secondary School

Introduction

AirPublic provide air pollution monitoring services, particularly focused on NO2 and PM. We installed devices in the playground of Grey Coat Hospital School (GCHS) between 28th August 2018 and 22nd February 2019.

The Grey Coat Hospital, founded in 1698, is a Church of England school for girls aged eleven to eighteen which is mixed in the Sixth Form. It is located in the borough of Westminster in London.

Air Pollution is a known challenge in London, which has increased in public awareness in recent years. Of particular concern currently are Nitrogen Dioxide (NO2), and Particulate Matter (PM), this study focuses on NO2. In city environments vehicles are one of the the main contributors to NO2 emissions, particularly diesel cars. 

Location

Screenshot 2018-06-17 at 12.53.36.png

GCHS is located between four roads. While the two streets on the West and South side are quiet, Horseferry Road, bordering the North and East side carries high volumes of motor traffic, especially taxis. A bus stop is located at the NW corner. Victoria Street, a main arterial road, is 100m away.

The school is also close to a fixed reference monitor operated by King’s College London (KCL) as part of the London Air Quality Network.

Screenshot 2018-06-17 at 12.53.51

The arrow here indicates the location of the AirPublic sensors in relation to the KCL sensor (ochre hut), when mounted in the school playground.

 

Activities

Screenshot 2018-06-17 at 12.54.09

  • AirPublic monitoring units were installed at the school during a period of 22 weeks, between August 29th 2018 and 22nd February 2019.
  • The units took a measurement of Nitrogen Dioxide every two minutes, and the readings have been collated into hourly averages.
  • The units were also co-located with the reference monitor to calibrate the readings.
  • The measurements have been processed into graphs and charts (shown below)
  • Recommendations have been made

 

Results

The results shown below are averages between multiple sensors over a period of 22 weeks.

The AirPublic units were placed on the edge of the playground on the side adjacent to Horseferry Road. The measurements produced (right column) show higher readings than those recorded by the nearby reference monitor (left column). In previous colocation experiments the units have shown themselves to correlate to reference monitors with an Rsqr of 0.7.

Screenshot 2018-06-17 at 12.55.25

The readings show exceedances of the annual legal limit of 40 µg/m³, although not exceedances of the hourly limit of 200 µg/m³. If these averages were to hold for a yearly period this area would be in breach of current legislation.

The exceedances are noted between the hours of 6.00am to 10.00am, and 5.00pm to 9.00pm, with the morning period giving the highest average measurements.

During the weekdays the lowest average measurements were between 12.00 and 3.00pm.

Recommendations

Based on the readings shown the following recommendations could be made:

  1. Playtimes or PE lessons in the playground could be scheduled between midday and 3.00pm when the pollution levels are lowest
  2. Planting across the whole of the external fencing could be considered to lessen the spread of airborne pollutants into the playground area from the road. Planting should preferentially be species which have lots of leaves which have small hairs on them such as Ivy. (An example supplier is Plantman). This will mainly support reduction in particulate matter. 
    • Screenshot 2018-06-17 at 12.55.41
  3. The location of the bus stop is not appropriate, right next to the playground area. We recommend asking Transport for London to consider moving the bus stop to a different location.
  4. Finally, the school can continue to build on any work carried out in travel planning, encouraging parents to car share, or walk or cycle to school and therefore reduce their own contribution to the problem. Walk to School week can be a good way to spark this off, and other initiatives such as Walk once a Week, Bike to School Week or Walking Buses could also be considered.

Top image courtesy of Grey Coat Hospital

Debrief: OrganiCity Experimenter Workshop

1-hQtB3nT5qR0CKOJfnLj5Mg

Thursday signalled the end of AirPublic’s involvement in the OrganiCity project after four months of experimentation and co-creation. Together, with nine other London based experimenters, we have put OrganiCity’s nascent urban tech tools to the test and provided a rich and in-depth feedback to the OrganiCity tech team on where and how the OC platform can improve to better suit systems such as the AirPublic sensor network.
The OrganiCity project is an interesting and timely intervention, in an urban-tech ecosystem largely dominated by the IoT superpowers of Cisco, Amazon, IBM etc. OrganiCity is concerned with the future development of the urban technology ecosystem and the media (or mediums) through which we interact with the city in the coming decades. As Belen Palacio, project lead for OrganiCity in London, mentioned at Thursday’s event, previous visions of these ideas came in the form of ‘corporate dashboards’ — corporate conglomerates imagined a future of vast banks of control computers, knobs and dials and a central command and control system for the future city, akin to Chile’s 1970 Project Cybersyn.

As these ideas, and technology, have proceeded apace, the reality of these future cities is increasingly clear and resemble less a hierarchical command and control structure, and more a broad and complex array of If This Then That (IFTTT) algorithms. If the level of air pollution is high on street x, then alter traffic flow to prevent buildup and recommend cyclists and pedestrians an alternative cleaner route. If tube line y is offline, then prioritise automatic redistribution of public hire bikes to compensate travel options, etc.
The key here is, as Belen advocated during her talk, the value of developing these processes together, with the citizen and the urban dweller as central to the design process of these new systems. We all know what bad design looks like and what it’s capable of. OrganiCity is about experimenting at scale with new city tools and processes and designing with the citizen in mind, first and foremost. To view Belen’s presentation slides, see here.
Following on from Belen, Hannah Gardiner & John Cant from the AirPublic team debriefed on our 4 month long experimentation period and our experience using the OrganiCity platform. Hannah spoke at length on how AirPublic has shifted it’s focus from public hire bikes to electric delivery vehicles, and how during the experiment period we developed and iterated upon three new air quality sensor system prototypes purpose built to integrate with electric delivery vehicles and how we produced and deployed ten of these sensors to Gnewt Cargo’s London fleet. The images below are a product of these experiments across the London area:

1-0pTgvhDTL3DTRZ948LNW5g
Mapping air quality in central London. Each coloured circle represents a location which has been repeatedly measured, at least 20 times, in a short period of time. Air quality is represented from Green to Red, Low to High pollutant counts. Each spot represents a 20m x 20m area.
1-XNv7Z-Y95KvGQZm4F5tqXg.png
Obfuscated visualisation showing the breadth of the AirPublic experiment. Green areas have good coverage.

John gave an in-depth breakdown of feedback on AirPublic’s use of the OrganiCity platform and its constituent parts, including Sensinact (SN), the Urban Data Observatory (UDO) and Tinkerspace. The AirPublic slides from Thursday, here, provide some more information. We’ll be writing up a public blog reporting back on our experiment in full in the next week or so.
Our final speaker, Fabrizio Dini, from traffic monitoring startup TrafficFlow, gave an overview of the trajectory of TrafficFlow’s work and their progress as part of the OrganiCity project. In London, they placed three traffic monitors, in Hoxton Square, on Bethnal Green Road and another at the Open Data Institute — in addition to another 10 in Florence, Italy. Fabrizio gave an in-depth overview and analysis of the data they have collected over the last four months, including an impressive breakdown of traffic data on London roads into their constituent parts — pedestrians, buses, cars, bicycles etc- all produced from a simple monitoring kit the size of a Raspberry Pi.

1-BlZghOsC2J8qt_Ol0W8zzA.png
TrafficFlow monitoring platform placed in Newspeak House, Shoreditch.

For the last part of our evening, we broke out into groups and provided an opportunity for participants to feed back on what they’d seen and heard regarding the experimenter projects and, more widely, the OrganiCity project as whole.
Thanks again from the whole AirPublic team to those who attended. If you’d like to view the slides from Belen you can find them here, and the slides from TrafficFlow & AirPublic, here. We’ll be releasing a public report blog on our progress as part of the OrganiCity project over the next week. You can find out more about the OrganiCity project here, including registering your project for the next Open Call.